Using Phil's SIG 228 9mm, we fired one shot in each pumpkin from appr. 21 feet. We used 3 kinds of ammo. WWB ball ammo, Hornady TAP 147gr HP, and SPEER Gold Dot +p HP.
WWB Ball ammo:
SPEER Gold dot:
For .40 cal, we used Jeff's SIG 229. WWB Ball ammo, and Winchester Supreme HPs.
Winchester WB ball ammo:
The clear winners were the Supreme and the Hornady TAP.
On to the fun part - rifles!